As July was getting started, we felt compelled to stand up for the most vulnerable people in our community who had been recently vilified by a majority of the most powerful court in the land.
The decision released by the U.S. Supreme Court in the waning days of June provided a path for cities like ours to criminalize the act of sleeping outside, reversing an appellate court decision that prohibited cities from criminally charging unhoused people when no shelter is available to them.
Pima County Attorney Laura Conover and Adelita Grijalva, chair of the Pima County Board of Supervisors held a news conference on July 2, making clear that despite the SCOTUS decision, people in Pima County would not be treated as criminals simply because they have no place to go.
The decision in the case out of Grants Pass, Oregon is a misguided attempt to take people off the streets by putting them behind bars, Laura told local reporters.
It falsely suggests that we can arrest our way out of chronic homelessness, substance abuse disorder, or mental illness, she said. It is unfunded, leaving local police and prosecutors to finance jailing the homeless at the expense of other initiatives intended to make communities safer, distracting from more appropriate efforts to address illness, housing, and poverty that are making a difference.
“Most importantly, the Supreme Court is wrong. Morally, ethically wrong,” she said. “Despite the overwhelming challenges of COVID, homelessness, crime, and fentanyl, Pima County never lost sight of the humanity, and I’m here to make sure we don’t. While the Supreme Court is willing to tolerate cruelty, this community will not.”
Chair Grijalva noted the Pima County’s struggles with affordable housing stock and the limited funding needed to reduce or eliminate chronic homelessness and adding criminal charges is not the solution.
“I want to make one thing very clear,” she said. “We cannot arrest our way out of the problem facing our community members and many other communities across the nations. Being unhoused is not a crime.”
And in Pima County, it won’t be treated as one. Video of the press conference can be seen here